No, a Murdoch newspaper is not urging readers to kick the Prime Minister out of office

No, a Murdoch newspaper is not urging readers to kick the Prime Minister out of office

What was claimed

The verdict

The Daily Telegraph published a front page photo of Prime Minister Scott Morrison with a headline telling readers,  “Finally you now have the chance to…Kick This Rat Out.”

Altered Content. A screenshot of the front page of The Daily Telegraph was digitally altered to add Mr Morrison’s head to the body of former prime minister Kevin Rudd whose photo was originally published with a different headline.

By Catherine Smith

A doctored image that purports to show the front page of a News Corp newspaper urging readers to vote Prime Minister Scott Morrison out of office has been repeatedly shared on social media ahead of the federal election on May 21.

The image shows the cover page of News Corp paper, The Daily Telegraph, depicting a photo of Mr Morrison, alongside the headline “Finally you now have the chance to…Kick This Rat Out.”

The image was posted on Facebook by AusPol’s right-wing lunatic watch — a page that claims to “expose the right-wing lunatics in Australia. MP's, journalists, commentators, voters and trolls on social media”. The page has more than 10,000 followers.

A reverse image search reveals that the original image was taken from the front page of The Daily Telegraph, published on August 5, 2013. It featured former Australian Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd, with the headline; “Finally, you have the chance to…kick this mob out”. 

But the image has been doctored to add Mr Morrison’s head to Mr Rudd’s body, and the headline has been altered to instead read “Kick this Rat Out”. The pink banner at the top of the page has also been changed from “It’s On: September 7 Election”, to “It’s On: May 21 Election”.

FactLab: Original The Daily Telegraph front page published August 5, 2013 (left) and altered image posted on Facebook (right) Original front page of The Daily Telegraph, August 5, 2013 (left). Altered image posted on Facebook (right)

Dr Richard Matthews, a digital forensics expert who has worked with INTERPOL, told RMIT FactLab that it can be tricky to spot a doctored image but there are visual clues to look for. 

“The tell-tale signs to look for in a potential photo composite image are contradictory sources of light, shadows, reflections and physical properties that simply cannot exist in the real world,” he said.

“The shadows on Mr Morrison's face indicate that there is a light source coming from above and a second from behind him directed downward. However, the lighting on the shirt and tie show that there is a light source at a more general angle,” he said.

“The photo is taken on a higher resolution camera or simply taken closer to the subject. There is a sharp line of contrast around the neckline of the shirt and around the head itself,” he said.

 

The verdict

Altered content. A screenshot of the front page of The Daily Telegraph which, in 2013, published a photo of Kevin Rudd with the headline “Kick this mob out” has been digitally altered to replace Mr Rudd’s head with that of Prime Minister Scott Morrison alongside a headline that reads, “Kick this rat out”, giving the impression that a Murdoch newspaper is asking readers to vote Mr Morrison out of office at the federal election on May 21.

03 May 2022

Share

aboriginal flag
torres strait flag

Acknowledgement of Country

RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT University respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waters across Australia where we conduct our business - Artwork 'Luwaytini' by Mark Cleaver, Palawa.