Tech companies are not used to considering data ownership, expert warns

Tech companies are not used to considering data ownership, expert warns

Australian authors have been caught up in a dataset of pirated ebooks, called Books3, which has allegedly been used by Meta to train generative AI.

While we await the legal implications of tech companies using copyrighted, creative works, an RMIT expert warns that tech companies have always operated this way – it’s just that now, the game has changed and the stakes are higher.

Dr Dana Mckay, Senior Lecturer in Innovative Interactive Technologies, School of Computing Technologies

“Tech companies are accustomed to using data found on the internet without considering ownership – such as indexing text for search engines.

“There are good historical reasons for this. Without indemnity for both indexing and linking to content, that might be in itself illegal, search engines wouldn't exist.

“For the most part this situation has benefitted creators and search engines – links to books are advertising for those books.

“Where search tools have been created specifically to provide access to copyrighted content without payment, those tools have faced successful legal challenges (such as the Napster case over 20 years ago).

“For tech companies, using books to train AI models may seem a natural next step from search indexing: ingest content, do their thing with it, present content to the user.

“For authors, artists and other creatives, though, this breaks the link to their original content, thus eliminating any opportunity to track or receive fair compensation for use of their works.

“Meanwhile, AI companies are monetising the use of those works, up to and including producing work 'in the style of' a creator.

“Use of copyright works comes with the responsibility to attribute and pay for that use.

“If we, as a society, want the joy, beauty, and humanity that creative works inspire, we need to make the key distinction between linking to work, and ingesting it.”

Dr Dana McKay studies the intersection of people, technology and information, and her focus is on ensuring advances in information technology benefit society as a whole.

***

General media enquiries: RMIT Communications, 0439 704 077 or news@rmit.edu.au

11 October 2023

Share

11 October 2023

Share

  • STEM
Engage

Related News

music-melbourne-recital-centre-1220x732.jpg

Making music for stairwells, foyers and transient spaces

What if music can be created beyond the stage – in a building’s foyers and stairways? Who said stairwells were just for stairs?

women-in-cyber-security-1220x732.jpg

Study reveals the reasons women leave cyber security: bullying, 24/7 culture, pay gap

New research from RMIT University has investigated why women are under-represented in Australia’s cyber security workforce and why the few that do enter the sector, often end up leaving it.

Large group of students posing in front of stage.

Animations add new dimension to orchestra performance

Animations by RMIT design students featured in a Melbourne Symphony Orchestra (MSO) performance led by Principal Viola Christopher Moore.

Group of around twenty symposium attendees.

Symposium examines creative practice in the Asia-Pacific region

RMIT and LASALLE College of the Arts have co-hosted the Imaging Pasts and Futures: Creative Digital Practices in the Arts symposium in Singapore.

Show more
aboriginal flag
torres strait flag

Acknowledgement of Country

RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT University respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waters across Australia where we conduct our business - Artwork 'Sentient' by Hollie Johnson, Gunaikurnai and Monero Ngarigo.

More information