Australians paying $6 billion for unused apartment parking

Experts are calling for planning policy to ‘unbundle’ parking spaces from apartments to reduce housing costs and alleviate street parking woes.

A new RMIT University study surveyed more than 1,300 apartment residents across Melbourne, Sydney and Perth to assess the adequacy of off-street parking for apartment households.

Lead researcher Dr Chris De Gruyter from the Centre for Urban Research said two thirds of households owned the same number of cars as their allocated parking spots.

However, 20% of households had too much allocated parking, while 14% did not have enough.

De Gruyter said the imbalance of off-site parking for apartments reflected residents not having a choice in how many parking spots they needed when renting or buying an apartment.

In Victoria, there are minimum parking provisions that state every one and two-bedroom apartment must have at least one parking spot, and apartments with three or more bedrooms must have at least two.

“We found in our study that people living in larger apartments tend to have an oversupply of parking because of this policy, which means they’re paying for a space they’re not using,” De Gruyter said.

A Sankey chart showing the correlation between number of cars owned and number of car parking spaces allocated. Credit: Chris De Gruyter

De Gruyter said 13.4% of the surveyed households did not own a car but most were still allocated a parking space.

With each parking space worth up to $100,000, he estimated the price of unused off-site parking is costing residents more than $6 billion.

“This oversupply is not just an inefficient use of space, it is exacerbating housing affordability issues,” he said.

“Meanwhile, apartment households with an undersupply of parking are forced to park on the street, competing with visitors in the area.”

“It is very clear that there is actually plenty of apartment parking - it’s just allocated incorrectly.”

Unbundling for more choice

De Gruyter is calling for state and local governments to allow for unbundled parking in planning policy to help balance the over and undersupply of off-site parking.

He said unbundling parking was not about taking away parking from residents – it was about giving people the choice to own or rent parking spaces in line with their needs.

“We can choose the number of bedrooms we want in our homes, yet we have no say in how much parking we need,” he said.

“We want people to have the option to choose not to have parking instead of it being imposed on them. Similarly, those who wish to have additional parking can have this.”

13.4% of surveyed households did not own a car but most were still allocated a parking space. Credit: Adobe Stock

Unbundled off-street parking in apartment buildings is still uncommon in Australia, but they can be seen in several newer complexes, such as Melbourne Square, Indi City Sydney and Arklife in Brisbane, choosing to unbundle parking from apartments.

De Gruyter said it was promising to see the renewed Arden precinct in North Melbourne introduce planning policy to facilitate unbundled parking for their new buildings.

“Unbundled parking is going to help with housing affordability, reduce car use and on-street parking issues,” he said.

“We’re also going to see better health for residents as there will be more physical activity due to more public transport use, and better air quality from less car use.”

But waiting for the market alone to bring this change would be too slow, said De Gruyter, and state and local government had an important role to play.

“Do apartment residents have enough car parking? An empirical assessment of car parking adequacy in Australian cities” is published in the Journal of Transport Geography (DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2023.103542)

This research was led by RMIT University in collaboration with the University of Western Australia.

Chris De Gruyter, Paula Hooper and Sarah Foster are co-authors.

Story: Shu Shu Zheng

Society and Environment

30 March 2023

Return to RMIT News

Society and Environment

30 March 2023

Research
Sustainability
Society
Design
DSC
Property & Construction
Environment

Engage

Related News

RMIT University backs Vietnam with new $250m strategic investment fund

Today, in the presence of Australia’s Prime Minister, the Honourable Anthony Albanese MP, RMIT University announced the next phase of its Country Commitment to Vietnam, including a AUD $250 million strategic investment fund.

RMIT leading globally on sustainable development goals

RMIT has been ranked number one globally for its impact towards multiple sustainable development goals, according to the 2023 Times Higher Education University Impact Rankings.

A person is walking along the Maribyrnong River. The path is surrounded with plants. A bridge is visible in the distance.

Northsiders are more connected to nature than southsiders: study

New research into Melburnians’ connection to nature is helping the City of Melbourne understand how to engage its community members in conservation efforts.

Mining atlas helps map Australia's clean energy future

An industry-led collaboration is unlocking value in previously mined and discarded earth and rock to help boost Australia’s global position as a clean energy powerhouse.

Acknowledgement of Country

RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT University respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waters across Australia where we conduct our business - Artwork 'Luwaytini' by Mark Cleaver, Palawa.

More information

Australians paying $6 billion for unused apartment parking