Melbourne public transport services sit idle while apartment numbers boom

Melbourne public transport services sit idle while apartment numbers boom

New research shows the number of apartments in Melbourne has almost doubled in the past two decades, while public transport services have barely increased at all.

The nineteen-year longitudinal study, from RMIT’s Centre for Urban Research, showed the number of apartments increased by 88% between 2004-2022, while public transport services within walking distance of apartments only increased by 5%. 

Project lead and RMIT Senior Research Fellow, Dr Chris De Gruyter, said the slow growth of public transport services highlighted the need for housing development to include public transport in the planning process, especially if housing development focused on existing urban areas.

“Urban policy in the last few decades has shifted from suburban car-based development to encouraging more urban densification around public transport,” he said. 

“We’re seeing all these new apartments being built along public transport routes but we’re not seeing services step up to match those new apartment developments. 

“More needs to be done to better integrate transport and housing policies to improve the sustainability, productivity and liveability of our city.”

Trend analysis for metropolitan Melbourne of apartment housing development vs total population and public transport services (train, tram) within 800m of apartment dwellings between 2003-04 t0 2021-22. Apartment housing increased 88% over a 19-year period while public transport services with walking distances of apartments have only increased by 5%. Credit: Chris De Gruyter, Steve Pemberton and Eric Keys

Lead researcher and RMIT research assistant, Steve Pemberton, said there was little existing research that looked specifically at the relationship between the growth of apartment development and public transport services in Melbourne.

With the current metropolitan planning strategy, Plan Melbourne 2017 – 2050, aiming to locate 70% of new housing in established areas close to jobs and public transport, Pemberton said it was crucial to track growth from both a metropolitan and local level.

“There are considerable variations between individual areas which can tell us more about the equity between public transport services and apartments,” Pemberton said.

“These findings can be used to influence councils and local governments to make decisions specific to their area.” 

The research found apartment housing had grown by 102% along the 86 tram route, but tram services increased by just 0.3%.

Apartment housing between Jewell and Upfield stations along the Upfield line increased by 134% while public transport services only increased by 7%.

On the opposite end, the City of Frankston saw a growth of 16% in apartment housing but increased their train services by 58%.

A graph and map tracking apartment housing activity against public transport service provision along the upfield line between Jewell and Upfield stations.
A graph and map tracking apartment housing activity against public transport service provision in the city of Frankston. Researchers said public transport services were not matching the growth of apartment housing. Credit: Chris De Gruyter, Steve Pemberton and Eric Keys

Pemberton said it was not always clear why there was a difference in services between train lines or areas. 

“As far as we can see, there’s no pattern to why some areas have more frequent services than others,” he said.

"But what we can say is public transport services are not consistently matching the growth of apartment housing.

“There’s also little to no relationship between public transport supply and socio-economic advantage and disadvantage, so more advantaged areas with apartment housing do not necessarily receive a greater number of public transport services per person than less advantaged areas with apartment housing.

“It's probably fair to say that somewhere like Upfield is particularly hard to improve services because of the level crossings on high-volume roads, though it's hard to improve train services everywhere.” 

A graph that shows the changes between 2003-04-2021-22 across local government areas in apartment dwellings, total population and public transport sertices (trains, trams) within 800m of apartment dwellings. The slow growth of public transport services highlighted the need for housing development to include public transport in the planning process. Credit: Chris De Gruyter, Steve Pemberton and Eric Keys

Capacity-adjusted public transport not the right solution

The study also found a 35% increase in upgrades to larger-capacity public transport vehicles across Melbourne, mostly trains and trams, which was on par with population growth.  

However, Pemberton said capacity increases were not a service improvement.

“It’s true higher-capacity vehicles are a way for government to address population increases and avoid overcrowding with less cost than adding more services,” he said. 

“But from the perspective of passengers, they are still waiting long times between services. They’re just crammed into a bigger vehicle with more people.

“If the objective is to encourage people to live in higher density housing, then an uplift of public transport services in areas where density is increasing should be part of what helps make people want to live there.” 

“Tracking the development of apartment housing activity against public transport service provision in Melbourne: 2004-2022” was published by the Centre for Urban Research. 

Chris De Gruyter, Steve Pemberton and Eric Keys are co-authors. 

 

Story: Shu Shu Zheng

09 April 2024

Share

09 April 2024

Share

  • Sustainability
  • Society
  • Urban Design
  • Research
  • DSC Research
  • DSC
  • Environment
Engage

Related News

Photo of Monica Kerwin, Natika Clayton, Robert Clayton, Shalarna Thorpe

Funding of $6 million to support RMIT research to measure First Nations digital inclusion

The announcement is part of the Australian Government’s plan to invest $68 million to narrow the digital gap by supporting more First Nations communities to access the internet.

safety-health-innovation-network-thumbnail-1220x732-updated.jpg

Transforming construction health and safety with SHINe

RMIT has launched the Safety and Health Innovation Network (SHINe), an industry-led collaborative research funding model to identify and tackle problems across the construction industry.

World-first green hydrogen innovation wins prestigious Climate Innovation Challenge

South East Water and RMIT University's ground-breaking method for producing green hydrogen from solar energy and recycled water has won the 2024 Water Minister’s Climate Innovation Challenge.

music-melbourne-recital-centre-1220x732.jpg

Making music for stairwells, foyers and transient spaces

What if music can be created beyond the stage – in a building’s foyers and stairways? Who said stairwells were just for stairs?

Show more
aboriginal flag
torres strait flag

Acknowledgement of Country

RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT University respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waters across Australia where we conduct our business - Artwork 'Sentient' by Hollie Johnson, Gunaikurnai and Monero Ngarigo.

More information