Australia’s carbon markets risk penalising Indigenous stewardship

Carbon markets rewarding the recovery of degraded environments risk penalising long-term Indigenous stewardship, according to a coalition of experts writing in Nature Climate Change.

The article by RMIT University environmental science and legal experts working with a Yirrganydji Aboriginal Bama (Person) highlights growing frustration among traditional owners who often find their lands ineligible for carbon credits because they remain intact.

In contrast, landholders whose predecessors degraded ecosystems have opportunities to generate credits by restoring them.

Lead author and Director of RMIT’s Centre for Nature Positive Solutions Professor Peter Macreadie said this unintended consequence risked entrenching inequity and undermining the credibility of climate markets.

“Carbon markets were designed to reward climate action, but our research shows they may be producing a perverse outcome: rewarding those who damaged land in the past while excluding Indigenous custodians who for generations have cared for country,” he said.

The issue revolves around the definition of ‘additionality’, which is a core integrity requirement in carbon markets, intended to ensure credits are only issued for climate benefits that wouldn’t have occurred otherwise.

In practice, this often means restoration on degraded land is rewarded, while long-protected ecosystems are treated as the baseline and assumed to continue without support.

Professor Peter Macreadie measuring carbon sequestration in mangrove forests around Cairns. Credit: Through The Looking Glass Studio.

Brian Singleton, a Yirrganydji Aboriginal Bama and Land Manger, said his people have overseen stewardship of the Cairns area for thousands of years, long before there were conservation and ranger programs.

He said Indigenous people have largely been left out of the conversation when it comes to carbon markets.

"We need to be included so we can see the other value and opportunities in protecting what mangrove systems we still have. No matter how remote, we’re still facing climate challenges with dieback, erosion, wash off and pollution,” Singleton said.

“The real issue with the system is that proper consultation with traditional owners was not done when setting it up, and so now the work being done on country can’t be counted. It’s hard work and should be recognised by creating financial opportunities for it to continue.”

Singleton said it was also important to engage and incentivise young people to ensure ongoing care.

“Otherwise, if it’s not done, it will be bad news not just for people but for the environment,” he said.

Joint fieldwork team measuring carbon sequestration in the mangroves around Cairns Airport. Back row: George Singleton, Gavin Singleton, Ashlyn Skeene. Front row: Lucy Friend, Tarquin Singelton, Mathew Skeene, Peter Macreadie. Credit: Through The Looking Glass Studio.

Legal and policy pathways exist

RMIT legal scholar Dr Vanessa Johnston said aligning carbon markets with Indigenous custodianship could create pathways to broaden participation, improve climate outcomes and support ecosystems that underpin long-term mitigation.

“Achieving this requires integrity frameworks that recognise stewardship, not just restoration, as a legitimate form of climate action,” she said.

The team’s research outlines several recommendations to support fairer and more effective environmental outcomes, including:

recognition that maintaining intact ecosystems often requires active, under-funded governance, particularly where altered fire regimes, feral animals and changing water flows create threats

allowing conservative recognition of avoided degradation where such risks exist

ensuring Indigenous custodians can participate as project owners or equal partners, rather than peripheral stakeholders

RMIT's Dr Vanessa Johnston is an expert in environmental and climate law.

Johnston, an expert in carbon rights, property law and land use, said recognising stewardship within additionality was not a call for weaker standards, but an overdue correction to a framework designed without Indigenous governance in mind.

“It also aligns with a growing body of research that recognises land ownership as involving obligations of conservation and protection, not just entitlements,” she said.

Macreadie said bringing together legal perspectives, Indigenous experience and environmental science helped highlight tensions in how carbon market integrity rules were currently applied, and to explain why existing approaches are struggling.

“What we are seeing is climate finance systems built on good intentions backfiring because they fail to recognise stewardship, care and long-term ecosystem protection as legitimate climate action,” Macreadie said. “Clearly, something needs to change.”

‘Additionality requirements of carbon markets could penalise Indigenous stewardship’ is published in Nature Climate Change (DOI: 10.1038/s41558-026-02576-2)

Story: Michael Quin

Society and Environment

05 March 2026

Return to RMIT News

Society and Environment

05 March 2026

STEM
Industry
Indigenous Australia
Sustainability
Indigenous
CoBL
Research
Regenerative Futures
Environment

Engage

Contact RMIT News

Find an expert

Study with us

Research at RMIT

Related News

Global study identifies urgent blue carbon priorities in the fight against climate change

A major new international study warns that critical scientific and practical gaps are slowing the use of blue carbon ecosystems (BCEs) in global efforts to tackle climate change.

RMIT research opens door to better IVF experience

A wearable device to make fertility treatment easier is being developed by a Melbourne startup in partnership with RMIT, the University of Melbourne and Monash IVF.

Scientists take major step towards a working quantum battery

Australian researchers have demonstrated the world’s first proof-of-concept quantum battery, opening new possibilities for faster, more efficient energy storage.

Smart bandage could heal and monitor wounds at the same time

Researchers have unlocked the possibility of creating smart wound dressings that enable real-time monitoring while also being able to deliver healing agents in one simple, scalable platform.

Acknowledgement of Country

RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT University respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waters across Australia where we conduct our business - Artwork 'Sentient' by Hollie Johnson, Gunaikurnai and Monero Ngarigo.

More information

Australia’s carbon markets risk penalising Indigenous stewardship