Does government consultation actually work?

Does government consultation actually work?

A review panel examining the use of puberty blockers in gender affirming care in Queensland has been criticised for its lack of specialty expertise. So, are committees, consultations and inquiries just a matter of course – or do they serve a meaningful purpose? An RMIT expert explains.

Dr Kathryn Daley, School of Global, Urban and Social Studies

“The premise of consultation is that there are people who have expert views that will strengthen the quality of decisions being made.

“When this happens without appropriate experts, not only are decisions less informed, but the process of consultation is undermined.

“When there aren’t suitable experts on a committee or involved with consultation, we see a corruption of the process, which further undermines the public perception of how decisions are being made.

“Claiming that there is a working group sometimes offers politicians an opportunity to escape questioning. Any outcomes from the working group are often so far into the future that the politician escapes accountability. 

“It’s quite clear that there is a campaign to prohibit the use of puberty blockers in Queensland and the composition of the review panel appears to actively exclude those with lived experience of the very issue they are discussing. When processes appear to be contrived, this erodes public trust on all political decision making.

“The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child – to which Australia is a signatory – stipulates that young people have a right to participate and be included in decisions that are being made that affect them. Yet here we are, witnessing a group of people forming decisions without the people being affected by those decisions having a seat at the table.”

Dr Kathryn Daley is Associate Director of Social Equity Research Centre and a senior lecturer at RMIT. Her work is focused on improving the wellbeing of people living on the margins, particularly children and young people.

***

General media enquiries: RMIT External Affairs and Media, 0439 704 077 or news@rmit.edu.au

12 June 2025

Share

Return to RMIT News
12 June 2025

Share

Engage

Related News

image2.jpg

RMIT Advances Cyber Resilience Across the Asia-Pacific Region

Throughout the last few months, the College of Business and Law’s Centre for Cyber Security Research and Innovation (CCSRI) marked significant milestones in its cyber resilience and uplift initiatives across the Asia-Pacific region.

The team's experimental set up of hydrogen production using partially treated wastewater. Credit: Shu Shu Zheng, RMIT University

Wastewater contaminants boost green hydrogen production

Research led by RMIT University has developed an experimental invention to turn wastewater’s high contaminant load into an advantage for making green hydrogen that could reduce reliance on fresh water – a scarce resource in many parts of the world.

(L-R) Distinguished Professors Martyn Hook and Judith Bassant

Congratulations to RMIT’s newly appointed Distinguished Professors

Judith Bessant from the School of Global, Urban and Social Studies and Martyn Hook from the School of Architecture and Urban Design have been awarded Distinguished Professorships.

news-wetland-1220x732px.jpg

Restored wetlands reap benefits for climate, drought-resilience after just one year: study

Reviving floodplain wetlands slashes carbon emissions by 39% and restores critical ecosystem functions in one year – without the methane spike typically seen in restored peatlands, a new study has found.

Show more
aboriginal flag float-start torres strait flag float-start

Acknowledgement of Country

RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT University respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waters across Australia where we conduct our business - Artwork 'Sentient' by Hollie Johnson, Gunaikurnai and Monero Ngarigo.

More information