Fact check: Did Harold Holt abolish the White Australia policy?

RMIT ABC FactCheck investigates Liberal MP Tim Wilson's claims that former Prime Minister Harold Holt was responsible for abolishing the White Australia policy.

Image sourced from @TimWilsonMP

The claim

Australia's political establishment was quick to denounce the explosive first speech of Katter's Australian Party senator Fraser Anning and his call for a return to immigration policies that would discriminate against non-Europeans and Muslims.

Senator Anning lamented the loss of Australia's cross-party consensus which he said had "recognised the importance of our predominantly European identity", and laid blame for the demise of Australia's European-based immigration program on "the rise of [former prime minister Gough] Whitlam in the Labor party".

But Liberal MP Tim Wilson rebuffed that version of history.

Responding to the senator's speech he instead claimed credit for the Liberal Party, tweeting:

"Fact: Liberal Prime Minister Harold Holt abolished the White Australia Policy over 50 years ago. It is one of our proudest achievements."

Did former prime minister Harold Holt end the White Australia policy? RMIT ABC Fact Check investigates.

The verdict

Mr Wilson's claim is simplistic.

The White Australia policy was dismantled, piece by piece, over decades spanning governments both Liberal and Labor.

Experts told Fact Check the 1966-67 Holt government's reforms were critical steps in the process, constituting a significant break from past practice.

Mr Holt's changes levelled the playing field between Europeans and non-Europeans applying for citizenship, setting a 5-year wait time for both groups, and eased the criteria for non-European migrants seeking permanent residence.

But the process of relaxing Australia's discriminatory immigration policies quietly began before Mr Holt became prime minister — and policies of racial discrimination persisted beyond his term.

So it is a stretch to say the Holt government "abolished" the White Australia policy.

Responsibility for officially ending it fell to Gough Whitlam's Labor government, which in 1973 declared the policy dead.

The Whitlam government then took steps to strip race as a factor from visa assessments and to equalise the criteria by which all people — whether British, European or otherwise — could become Australian citizens.

What was the White Australia policy?

Associate Professor Gwenda Tavan, acting head of La Trobe University's Department of Politics and Philosophy, told Fact Check that White Australia was a euphemism for what was both a national doctrine about the "essential Australian identity" and a general policy of keeping Australia "white and British Australian".

It was, in effect, a set of regulations and laws that severely restricted non-European immigration to Australia and controlled the rights migrants had in relation to work, benefits and citizenship.

Andrew Markus, a research professor with Monash University, said that after World War II there wasn't anything formally called the White Australia policy, and that post-war governments were more likely to refer to Australia's "established immigration policy".

 

Principal Researcher: David Campbell

For the full story, please visit the RMIT ABC FactCheck website.

 

06 September 2018

Share

06 September 2018

Share

  • Fact Check
  • Equality, Diversity & Inclusion
  • Government & Politics
  • Society

Related News

RMIT Vietnam launches digital education centre

A new Centre of Digital Excellence at RMIT Vietnam has been launched by Victoria’s Minister for Training and Skills, Steven Herbert.

Research set to take European forest assessment to new heights

The use of low-cost and lightweight unmanned aerial vehicles to assess forest health in Europe is the focus of a research collaboration between RMIT and the Italian National Research Council.

RMIT students design ACMI’s first ever line of merchandise

The Australian Centre for the Moving Image (ACMI) has launched a fresh line of merchandise locally designed and produced in collaboration with RMIT textile design students.

RMIT student awarded European internship with industry leader

An RMIT engineering student has spent two months in the south of Spain working on an innovative solar energy project for one of the country's largest chemical groups.

Subscribe to RMIT NewsSubscribe
Flag Image One Flag Image Two

Acknowledgement of Country

RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT University respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waters across Australia where we conduct our business.

More information