Report reveals grim reality for Australia’s migrant meat workers

Report reveals grim reality for Australia’s migrant meat workers

A new RMIT University report launched by the ACTU gives voice to the experiences of Pacific Island workers in Australia’s meat industry who say they feel trapped and exploited.

The report launched today – Meat the reality: unpacking the exploitation of PALM scheme workers in Australia’s meat industry – calls for further improvements to address worker exploitation in the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) scheme, beyond changes made in 2024. 

The Australian Government scheme provides foreign workers temporary visas to work in meatworks and other industries with labour shortages.  

As well as providing a detailed legal critique and recommendations for reform, the report reveals personal experiences of five PALM scheme workers who each took photographs to represent their daily lives. The researchers used these photographs as prompts for in-depth discussions with the participants. 

Report co-author Professor Shelley Marshall.Report co-author Professor Shelley Marshall.

Professor Shelley Marshall from RMIT’s Business and Human Rights Centre (BHRIGHT) said the photographs and interviews revolved around themes of darkness, injustice and feelings of being trapped.  

“The participants in our study were sent to isolated rural towns, far from familiar faces, and placed in shared housing with strangers,” she said.   

“The photos hauntingly depict how they rarely see daylight due to physically demanding shifts, which are often extended with overtime, leading to an oppressive sense that their lives are consumed entirely by work.” 

Study participant Mafu’s daily view as he leaves and returns home in endless darkness.Study participant Mafu’s daily view as he leaves and returns home in endless darkness.

“At work, these workers are often burdened with lifting heavier meat – a demand fuelled by racial stereotypes about their strength – yet earn less than colleagues on other visa schemes," Marshall said. 

"Outside work, they are stripped of the full tenancy rights enjoyed by most Australians and are forced to endure high rents that are automatically deducted from their wages."

RMIT study co-author Ema Moolchand said these challenges were compounded by a visa condition requiring the employer’s permission for a worker to quit and seek work elsewhere.   

“Dependence on employers – even if they are clearly bad bosses – remains a key source of feelings of being trapped and unable to do anything about poor conditions, especially when workers face racial stereotypes or restricted freedom that further limit their ability to act,” Moolchand said. 

Study participant Enele photographed towering pallets and lower drums as a visual metaphor for perceived ethnic–based pay inequality.Study participant Enele photographed towering pallets and lower drums as a visual metaphor for perceived ethnic–based pay inequality.

The researchers are calling for more to be done to improve conditions for PALM workers, with those in the study saying they’d seen little improvement following changes made by the Government in 2024. 

The report found while an attaché from each country had been appointed to support and represent workers, those surveyed had not met them and did not know who they were. Participants also alleged illegal deductions were widespread. 

“As the first empirical study since important changes to the PALM scheme, this report highlights the need for a completely new approach to the scheme that genuinely prioritises worker voices and ensures fair, safe and dignified working conditions,” Moolchand said.  

Report co-author and PhD candidate Ema Moolchand.Report co-author and PhD candidate Ema Moolchand.

Launching the report, Australian Council of Trade Unions President Michele O’Neil said the findings align with the experience of unions that represent PALM workers, showing these challenges to be systemic problems rather than isolated incidents. 

“This report adds a human voice to what we already know are significant and ongoing issues with a scheme that ties PALM workers to their employer; the lack of mobility for workers to change employers poses a clear modern slavery risk.” 

"Among the changes we are calling for, mobility for these workers is paramount, as it would mean they can move to another approved employer if they need to leave a bad boss, unsafe conditions or harassment," O’Neil said. 

"This would mean employers could no longer treat PALM workers as bonded labourers." 

O’Neil also said a better scheme would ban employers who do the wrong thing. 

Marshall said the photovoice methodology used to share stories of the five participants in the study did not claim to be a representative survey sample for all PALM scheme workers. 

“This methodology is one that’s useful to help us understand the experiences of people who live in a very different situation from our own in detail. It is more a deep dive than a representative sample, that aids more comprehensive legal analysis,” Marshall said. 

“It’s important when discussing the well-documented issues with this scheme that voices and experiences of those living it are part of that debate.”

The study was led by Ema Moolchand as part of her PhD, co-supervised by Dr Matt Withers at the Australian National University and Professor Shelley Marshall at RMIT.  

 

Story: Michael Quin

11 February 2025

Share

Return to RMIT News
11 February 2025

Share

  • Research
  • Society
  • Sustainability
Engage

Related News

North Geelong Warriors FC players celebrate goal

Beyond the pitch: the mental health benefits of girls’ sport

A surge in girls’ soccer participation, driven by the Matildas’ success and growing national momentum, is delivering benefits well beyond the pitch, with new research highlighting its role in supporting adolescent mental health.

Mangroves_thumbnail.jpg

Australia’s carbon markets risk penalising Indigenous stewardship

Carbon markets rewarding the recovery of degraded environments risk penalising long-term Indigenous stewardship, according to a coalition of experts writing in Nature Climate Change.

2026 Distinguished Professors

Newly awarded Distinguished Professorships recognise excellence in research and leadership

Nine academics from across RMIT University have received the high honour, which is awarded to Level E academics who have achieved outstanding impact throughout their career.

Sneaky Sound system

RMIT community comes together to celebrate the Class of 2025

With Sneaky Sound System setting the scene and honorary degrees awarded to two outstanding leaders from the art and business communities, the 2025 RMIT Melbourne Graduation Ceremony was full of highlights.

Show more
aboriginal flag float-starttorres strait flag float-start

Acknowledgement of Country

RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT University respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waters across Australia where we conduct our business - Artwork 'Sentient' by Hollie Johnson, Gunaikurnai and Monero Ngarigo.

More information